Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Reform or Perish

.
Its all been said before, back & forth we go about Prem, Thaksin, uneducated masses, corrupt, selfish, manipulative, greedy elites & military, police, politicians, third hands, thainess, aversion to loss of face etc etc etc.

Hopefully I have the self control to make this my final comment on Thai politics:

Now is the time for Abhisit to decide how he wants to go down in history - it's his choice whether he is seen as another in a long line of elite manipulators, or a true reformer.

Whichever route he chooses, he is unlikely to win a fair election in the short term, but if he chooses reform he at least will eventually be fondly remembered by the majority
(and he is actually young enough that he might one day win an election fair & square, once the masses realize that no one is semi-divine, not HMK nor Thaksin)

Choose wrongly, and blowback is inevitable.

Obviously, there are quite a few others who also could make a difference, but I still think the most important players are still Thaksin, Prem & Abhisit.

Thaksin & Prem have already had ample opportunities to change and have shown no sign of doing so - time is not on Prem's side and his successor is unlikely to have nearly as much clout, so unless they are bloodyminded & stupid enough to go the Burma route, change is inevitable.

Thaksin is in a lot of hot water now, but I dont think it is too late for him to change - if he started to show some remorse and humility, he could be back sooner than expected - and I don't mean grovelling to Prem, rather he needs to be honest about the good and the bad of his own past actions - if he can do that there is probably no need for the yellow shirts to even exist.

Whether the red shirts need to exist will depend on what Abhisit does, but he has had enough warning from events over this Songkran, that if he chooses wrongly then the next uprising will be much bigger and harder to quell (especially if the reds have dropped the blind allegiance to Thaksin by then)

It's up to the Thais to sort the mechanics of the reform, but obviously the constitution rewrite needs to be an inclusive consultative process, and any remaining contentious items will have to go to a fair referendum, with all sides having an equal opportunity to present their arguments.

Before that reform can even happen, the first obstacle to be tackled is whether to prosecute all leaders on both the yellow and red sides, or to grant amnesties all round - whatever they choose, both sides need to be treated equally, otherwise there will be blowback one way or the other.

I wish them good luck in sorting this political mess out, so they can then move on to resolving the Southern Thailand insurgency.
Make the wrong moves and the south wont be the only place where there is an insurgency.

Thailand needs change, the genie is out of the bottle, and the old ways to put it back in will no longer work - heed the warnings!

7 comments:

anon said...

How many Democrat Premiers have actually gone down in history as reformers? Zero. Seni Pramoj opened his legs to the military in the 1970s and Chuan constantly blocked the reform efforts that led the 1997 Constitution. Banharn was more of a contributor to the 1997 Constitution than Chuan!

I'd be shocked if Abhisit ever becomes more than the poodle to the military and the PAD that he's been shown to be over the past 5 months.

hobby said...

He will reap what he sows.
(eventually)

maverick263 said...

i said it elsewhere.

& i'll say it again.

i like Abhisit :-) imho, he's doing a fine job.

confronted with the mess that makes up contemporary thai situation... ->

& seriously handicapped by powers around him ->

i've to say: his performance is amazing. handling of challenges foster his authority. & that, actually, _might_ allow him opportunities to start deep reform.

i might add: honestly, i don't see any other political representative. if critical Thai want a reform of their political system --- they shd support him. & engage in political dialogue & the nitty-gritty of daily politics.

it's just my opinion. an expression of hope for Thai society at large. :-)

hobby said...

I basically agree Abhisit looks a lot better that his competitors, but he does need to walk the reconciliation walk, not just talk it.

For instance, how can Kasit still be FM????

IMO, conceding some things enhances one reputation, and does not make you appear weak (as long as you draw a line in the sand on the really important things - like he did with the lawlessness on the weekend)
I'm still not sure how he pulled it off, and who had a word in who's ear, but it turned out much better than it looked like it was going to.

Regular Reader said...

Hobby,I see you have given up trying to move David Brown on, over at New Mandela.
I gave up on him several weeks ago.
Sadly, his opinions are set in stone.

hobby said...

Yes, just going round in circles with no one really prepared to give any ground - quite depressing really!

Regular Reader said...

There appear to be quite a few of them over there like that.
It's as if they still fighting a battle "that was", rather than what is- now.
Many of the old forces are still in place, but one has to recognize this has not gone according to anyone's plan... on either side - so far.
And, considering it involves the whole nation, at a major crossroad, you might as well tear up the "rule books"on crises in Thailand!